top of page

Inglorious Basterds (2009) Review

Writer: Julio Ramirez
Julio Ramirez
3 days ago
9 min read


THE FOLLOWING REVIEW CONTAINS SPOILERS OF THE DISCUSSED FILM.

READERS DISCRETION IS ADVISED.


It ain’t easy to decide what to commit the greater good because when it comes down to it, breaking some rules may be required. 
PLOT
2009’s Inglourious Basterds is the sixth film directed by writer Quentin Tarantino which takes place in 1941, unrelated to a 1978 film of the same name.
‘Chapter One: Once upon a time… in Nazi Occupied France’ shows SS Standartenführer Hans Landa, known as ‘The Jew Hunter’ for his uncanny ability in tracking down Jewish families, track down the Dreyfus family hiding under the home’s floorboards of a French farmer. The only one who survives is a young Shoshanna who is tauntingly spared by Landa.
‘Chapter Two: Inglorious Basterds’ shows US army first lieutenant Aldo Raine assemble his own black ops commando unit mixed of Jewish American soldiers, The Basterds, meant to instill fear on German Nazis by killing and scalping them. For those that live, he carves swastika masks on their foreheads so they cannot hide their affiliations after the war. His team includes the likes of: Privates First Class Smithson Utivich & Omar Ulmer, Austrian born translator Corporal Wilhelm Wicki, sergeant Donny Donowitz who earns the nickname ‘The Bear Jew’ for pummeling Nazis with a baseball bat, and rogue German sergeant Hugo Stiglitz, famously known for successfully murdering 13 Gestapo soldiers and was broken out of Berlin when recruited by Aldo. Through an ambush, they’re able to get information of another patrol when forcing other Nazis to direct them where.
‘Chapter Three: German Night in Paris’ fast forwards to 1944, showing Shoshanna to own a theater in Paris under the fake name Emanuelle Mimieux. Her beauty gets the attention of German sniper Frederick Zoller, who is star of propaganda film ‘Nation’s Pride’, which is about how he held his own alone in a bell tower against a battalion of Allied soldiers. He arranges her to meet Adolf Hitler’s Third Reidh number two man Joseph Goebbels (Sylvester Groth). Goebbels is the leader of the German film industry and with Zoller’s influence, he proposes hosting the premiere of Nation’s Pride in her theater. When she sees Landa again who is assigned to be head of security for the premiere and does not give any clarification if he recognizes her or not, the encounter becomes her motivation to burn down the theater on premiere night via flammable nitrate films.
‘Chapter Four: Operation Kino’ shows British Lieutenant Archie Hicox be assigned by General Ed Fenech to join an attack on the Nations Pride premiere where he must set off explosives with the Basterds that will be meant to kill the likes of Goebbels. He goes to a tavern in Nadine called La Louisiana meant to rendezvous with German actress and allied agent Bridget Von Hammersmark to share what she knows of the premiere. He goes with Stiglitz and Wicki, but it slowly goes wrong when a Wehrmacht sergeant Wilhelm (Alexander Fehling) is there to drunkenly celebrate the birth of his first child with his brothers in arms. Who is also present at the tavern is SS Sturmbannführer Dieter Hellström. At first, he doesn’t get too suspicious when playing the card game ‘Who Am I?’, but Hicox blows his cover by giving the wrong German hand gesture. It leads to a quiet standoff until everyone is shot down and only Hammersmark survives. Raine picks her up and she proves loyalty when revealing Hitler himself is also attending the premeire. Despite not knowing any Italian, the Basterds plan to sneak in by posing as Italian filmmakers. However when Landa investigates the tavern, he finds proof of Bridget’s presence such as her shoe being left behind and a signature she gave to one of the Nazis.
‘Chapter Five: Revenge of the Giant Face’ shows Shoshanna prepare for her epic revenge on premiere night, but it’s nearly foiled when Zoller finds her in the projection room. Unable to drive him away, she chooses to shoot him but he shoots her back and they die together. Landa sees through the Basterds’ cover and privately kills Hammersmark via strangulation before capturing Aldo and Utivich, whereas Donny and Ulmer go through with the plan and die killing Nazis in sight, including Hitler & Goebbel. As that happens, all Nazis die seeing Shoshanna’s face announcing her revenge, which was filmed & spliced by her Afro French projectionist and lover Marcel who also lights the nitrates as planned. Aware that the Nazis were at the brink of losing, Landa chooses to negotiate with the OSS for a surrender hoping to secure remaining impunity. Aldo & Utivich reach Allied territory with Landa and his radio operator Hermann (Michael Kranz), but Aldo kills and Utivich scalps the latter to reject the spirit of the deal so that Landa doesn’t escape unpunished. The film ends with Aldo branding Landa with a swastika like he’s done with past Nazis, but declares the Jew Hunter to be his masterpiece.
THOUGHTS

As I was getting into Tarantino’s work in my youth, I would’ve not expected such a profound title live up to the bar he’s set in the past and boy does it ever. This is the first time he starts tampering with history and it works to his liking because who wouldn’t want to see an adventure that leads to a Nazi massacre? It sure isn’t the first of its kind, but it is somehow a fun ride no matter how you depict it. You can easily praise the costume and production design for giving an authentic approach for the period, but it’s really Robert Richardson’s cinematography that makes the magic of going from intense to exciting in a fluent back and forth pace. That’s the best approach you can for with moments like the opening farm interrogation and the tavern standoff that have become excellent examples of pure suspense to this day. Add this with signature over the top violence Tarantino has been known for such as the theater massacre, then you know how batshit crazy it’s bound to be. You just know you’re going for style if Samuel L Jackson is tasked to exposit/narrate Stiglitz and the nitrates. Post Kill Bill, you can tell Tarantino has become an eventful filmmaker especially when intending to retire with only 10 directorial features. With such an environment that goes from grounded to extravagant, you would wonder what is the point of all that transpires. After watching this many times, I think it gives an implication of how there is quite banality when it comes becoming and facing evil. When you know some actions weren’t worth taking upon, you’re either gonna make important changes or dig deeper into a swarm of trouble. This is the case when you see both sides of the coin of an infamous war unfold and follow N amazing ensemble. So you get your parody of Hitler when Martin Wuttke is onscreen in a short amount, but Hans Landa was the real threat here. Christoph Waltz dominated awards season in this villainous performance to the point of earning the Supporting Actor Oscar, as he would for Django Unchained playing the beloved Doctor King Schultz. Landa was horrifying of a presence throughout because he uses much charm to hide his malice until he needs to reveal the facade. That is how earns his gripping nickname. He’s proven to be a strategic sadist in the opening inspection by checking the pulse of the farmer’s daughter which is enough for him to confirm they were hiding exactly what he was looking for. And while we’re not sure if he knew who Shoshanna was at the restaurant, making it seem like a test when he orders milk and picks out a strudel dessert. He uses that to either echo her past or test her old dietary laws she’s learned as a Jew. I would assume this all implies he knows however so but if not, he is still being theatric in expressing control over her, leaving her in near shambles. When you later pay attention to an oppressing figure like August Diehl portrays Hellström, he’d sure be amused in how he gets things done. Landa allows Hitler and his followers to die because he want to ensure his own survival rather than go through the same defeat. Ironically, the manipulation he inflicted was only temporary once his intentions were clear. It is so easy to enjoy Brad Pitt as Aldo because he is the kind of leader that can reciprocate in being brutal but never really compromises. No matter how many things change, he doesn’t give up and keeps moving forward with his absolute. It is so fitting that he’s the one to give Landa such a comeuppance his charm beats his at that point. And it’s because of that attitude that many soldiers followed him to the end. BJ Novak was the lucky one in making Utivich the most composed while Omar Doom shows Ulmer to be right behind that mindset and Eli Roth depicts Donny to be his own level of unhinged. At that point, I wouldn’t mind seeing Donny in a loop swinging that bat on some more nazis. While Gedeon Burkhard showed Wicki to be the more soft spoken one, Til Schweiger portrayed Stiglitz to be most unhinged. Sadly, this batch didn’t blend well when paired with outsiders that shared the same goal. I enjoyed Michael Fassbender a lot as Hicox because he brings the right amount of sophistication to the group, but sadly it took one blind spot that cost his life and others. Diane Kruger fit into the mold very well as Bridget Von Hammersmark because given her line of work, being performance driven and nearly pretentious has helped her be a favorable ally until it wasn’t. Had she collected evidence of her presence at the tavern like the autograph and her shoe, she definitely would’ve gotten to live longer. Considering Landa was about to surrender, I did wonder why he still chose to kill her. Simply put, she was still an enemy of the state to him and and basically let his ego get the best of him, which doesn’t make it better. Of all people that would be most pleased to see the comeuppance Aldo gave him, it’d be one who survived his wrath and died reciprocating the action. Melanie Laurent arguably portrays Shoshanna as the unsung hero here because while she doesn’t know about the Basterds, she resiliently chooses to make an epic revenge. I mean recording herself laughing at the wrath she passes on is quite fitting after what she went through. It does makes sense she found common ground with Marcel since Jacky Ido portrays him to be quite adaptable and very loyal. Ironically, she loses her life to someone who sees himself as a hero but is far from it. Daniel Brühl is another standout as Zoller because he’s quite insecure not wanting to be defined by his affiliation yet still relishes it to the point where he expects Shoshanna to be interested. Apart from the fact he’s a Nazi, he makes it clear how self absorbed he is the moment she exposes how he can’t take no for an answer. Getting shot should’ve been his wake up call, but he still lets his entitlement getting the best of him when shooting back. As much as we wish Shosanna got to live to see her plan follow through, at least she still got to go out defiantly like the rest of the Basterds. This movie will always rock, but even dope stuff like this have some questionable moments upon rewatching. For starters, who was Shoshanna’s aunt that passed the theater to her? I know she’s living under a fake name, but I do wonder what led to her a young adult being trusted by someone who looked after her during the years she’s been running from Landa. Also, Zoller should deem it a best case scenario she didn’t know who he was if he doesn’t want to be defined by fame. You can’t swoon over a guy that kills people. Then again, I’m trying to figure out how she didn’t hear Nation’s Pride before meeting Zoller. If Nazis are occupying France in the 40s and she’s running a theater, she should’ve heard about it way before meeting Zoller. I don’t mind the dramatic reveal of Landa being confirmed as head of security but if that’s his position for the premiere, he should’ve been part of the meeting the same time Shoshanna arrives. Hell, it’s even a rookie move for Shoshanna to talk to Marcel of burning the theater down in the middle of the lobby when there are Nazis barely leaving outside. They’re lucky Zoller didn’t force his way in like he would on premiere night. And if all of Germany knows who Stiglitz is, I’m surprised Hellström didn’t recognize him. Then Bridget should’ve given a nudge to Hicox that he gave himself away with the wrong gesture before Hellström arms himself. Lastly if there’s security that capture Aldo & Utivich, there should’ve been security at the doors to prevent Marcel from barricading them. Ignore these things however, then you’ll enjoy Inglourious Basterds as a much entertaining military epic that earns the Best Picture Oscar nomination. If military adventures are your jam, see this now.

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

©2021 by The Thoughts of a Cinephile. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page