top of page

The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (2008) Review

Writer: Julio Ramirez
Julio Ramirez
4 days ago
7 min read
“Goodnight, Benjamin”
“Goodnight, Benjamin”


THE FOLLOWING REVIEW CONTAINS SPOILERS OF THE DISCUSSED FILM. READERS DISCRETION IS ADVISED.


The longer you get to live, the more of a journey you get to appreciate as will those that will miss you.
PLOT
Based on the titular F Scott Fitzgerald story published back in 1922, 2008’s The Curious Case of Benjamin Button takes place in 2005, following an elderly Daisy Fuller on her deathbed in a New Orleans hospital. With her daughter Caroline present, she tells her of how a blind clockmaker, Mr Gateau, made a backwards clock in 1918 as a memoir for the fallen in WW1. She then gives her a diary that belonged to a man named Benjamin Button. His earliest log takes him back to his being born of ‘18 with a genetic disease that makes him born wrinkled like an elderly adult. When his mother died giving birth to him, his biological father Thomas leaves him on the porch of a nursing home. There, he would be raised by a black couple, Queenie and Tizzy Weathers. As he grows up, Benjamin would mentally age forward but physiologically age in reverse. He would not walk until the age of seven after being healthy enough to walk without a wheelchair. By 1930, he would be about 12 years old where he met Daisy at a Thanksgiving party and remained close throughout each others childhood. He would also meet tugboat captain Mike Clark and would travel with him in 1936. Throughout said travels does Benjamin send letters to Daisy while she begins a ballet career. During 1941, he would have an affair with record breaking swimmer Elizabeth Abbott who was married to a chief minister of British trade mission in Murmansk. Benjamin would also volunteer with Captain Mike during WWII and the protagonist would sadly be one of the only survivors following a German U Boat attack. He wouldn’t return home until ‘45 when he’s 26 years old and by that time, Queenie would reveal that Tizzy passed away. He then catches up with Daisy in New Orleans, but surprisingly chooses to turn down her advances, not wanting to rush being intimate with her. After this does he officially meet his father for the first time since before WWII. This time he reveals his identity, chooses to explain his condition to him and passes on his button making estate before succumbing to his own terminal illness. He keeps his distance from Daisy when finding Daisy involved with another man, but would check in with her after being struck by a car that derails her ballet career. Feeling embarrassed of such an injury, she takes out her frustration on him by demanding him to stay out of her life. They would make up in 1962 when she returns to New Orleans and they would move in together around the time Queenie passes away. By 1967 when they’re comparable of physical age, Daisy announces she is pregnant with their first child but around the time she is born, Benjamin passes his assets to them before choosing to travel for the rest of the 70s. He wouldn’t return to see Daisy again until 1980 where he sees her with a new husband named Robert and their daughter grown up at the age of 12. The two choose to have one more affair before going their separate ways again. By 1990 when Daisy is widowed, she is alerted that Benjamin is now a physical pre teen gaining dementia. She chose to move into Queenie’s nursing home in ‘97 and took care of him until he passed away as a newborn that was nearly 85 years old; Around that time, Gateau’s clock is replaced with a digital clock. With this being the end of the diary, Caroline would be in shock realizing Benjamin was her father all along. As Daisy dies in the hospital, Caroline accepts her decision to keep such a secret. The film officially ends with Hurricane Katrina flooding Gateau’s clock that continuously ticks backwards. 
THOUGHTS
If you’ve kept track of David Fincher’s filmography by the end of the 2000s, you know most of it has been crime thrillers. For him to adapt a beloved fantasy drama was a game changer on his end and needless to say, he did not really disappoint. The whole ordeal is stunning to experience thanks to not only beautiful cinematography by Claudio Miranda, but an impressive makeup/VFX combo that creates believable reverse and forward aging for both the titular lead and love interest. It’s definitely the most unordinary narrative to unfold because you never thought there would be one like it where one human goes through reverse aging and that in turn leads to said individual have such an eventful life that makes him appreciate bit of good and bad that comes with it. I think apart from hearing a soothing score by Alexandre Desplat, I think writer Eric Roth is able to teach us always live in the moment no matter how old you are and to never gripe on what you can’t control such as things like loss because if you can’t help yourself doing one or the other, it’ll be harder to appreciate your life as a whole. That is exactly what ensues with a memorable lead performance by Brad Pitt. A lot of us adore Benjamin because he’s a withdrawn and observant individual that doesn’t let any setback get to his head. He’s one of a kind given his condition and refuses to let that hold him back to his potential. Because of that level of optimism, he gets to be moved of every chapter he creates thanks to each individual he meets. Edith Ivey plays pianist Mrs. Maple at the nursing home and her brief teachings with him taught him to focus on how you feel with action instead of the result of it. Ted Manson played a man also at the nursing home named Mr Dawes who shared the seven times being struck by lightning that teaches him to be grateful with the life he has. Rampai Mohadi portrays Ngunda Oti and he is the first mentor that expresses its okay to be different. Jason Flemying did show Thomas to be a resentful parent that felt his actions were the right after an act of cowardice, which is the only reason his son shares a saunter with him before it’s over for him, but it is the duo of Taraji P Henson & Mahershala Ali as Queenie & Tizzy that too teach Benjamin to expect the unexpected, which is the best advice for him in this case because that’s exactly what he went through. Benjamin may have not said much when they died, but there’s no denying he misses the nurture that not many were willing to give him at first. Jared Harris was a whole other delight as Captain Mike because him being unfiltered and embracing his artistic integrity with the tattoos he’s given himself further encourage Benjamin to be true to himself throughout, which made his death all the more sadder. It was even neat to see him find companionship with Elizabeth before he got to have the chance to be with Daisy because Tilda Swinton portrays her as one with her own case of yearning for more. When they meet, she becomes inspired to not be hard on herself and just work harder without expecting feedback. That led to her breaking her record as she wanted, which Benjamin happily saw on the news. Last but not least, Benjamin would not have been so melancholic had he not fallen in love for the first time. His relationship with Daisy reminds me a lot of Forrest Gump’s relationship with Jenny because they’re an opposites attract relationship Cate Blanchett shows that she’s visibly flawed by letting her ambition get the best of her. Despite how they lived different lives before and after all the time together, she always loved him for the kindred spirit she shared with him. No matter how far they were, they never forgot of each other. Even when she wasn’t sure how things wouldn’t turn out, she reciprocated her devotion when being his caretaker, which is where she differs from Jenny because I don’t think she’d do the same for Forrest. It was a tough secret to keep, but it was the right thing for Caroline to not know yet because a life like Benjamin’s would be so hard for her to comprehend at a young age. With an adult Julia Ormond showing her to be much pragmatic, she chooses to quickly forgive her mom before she’s gone because the last thing she needs to do would be to resent an act of the greater good. Whether or not she survives Hurricane Katrina, I’m sure she’ll keep trying living to the fullest like her father had the privilege to do. This movie is quite splendid on its own, but it still had a few moments I couldn’t help thinking of upon rewatching. For starters, I’m quite Thomas never dropped off Benjamin to a hospital rather than a nursing home. I feel like he still would’ve met Daisy at some point. Hell, that does make it a miracle not one elderly questioned it and he was never abducted for experimentation like a sci fi movie. I know it’s not that kind of movie, but you can never know with how people respond to such phenomenons. And god it’s so weird they don’t even address Benjamin’s relationship with Queenie’s biological daughter. It’s not like he didn’t like her, but he could’ve said he never had much of a relationship with her due to all the time he spent traveling around the world. Hell, Caroline shouldn’t even be surprised her mom wasn’t gonna talk about her dancing past given the trauma that ended it. I’m then surprised no one from CPS questioned Benjamin’s diary in one form or another, as in questioning his age let alone his relationship with Daisy. Ignore these things however, then you can still go on to say The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is an ideal Best Picture Oscar nominee for making you want to appreciate life more than you already have. If you dig thought provoking dramas that can warm your heart, check this out when you have the time.

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

©2021 by The Thoughts of a Cinephile. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page